Outside of the sphere

For today’s post, I would like to briefly digress from South American football and instead talk about the appointment of Gerardo “Tata” Martino as the new head coach of Barcelona. Since the Argentinian was first linked with the vacancy, I have been inundated with questions about his character, his style and his philosophy. It seems that he is something of an unknown quantity outside of South America.

Before reading today’s post, I suggest reading this article that I wrote in November of last year, which explains Martino’s footballing ideology in great detail, and Jonathan Wilson’s piece for The Guardian yesterday, which goes deeper into Tata’s history and career.

The main question mark over Gerardo Martino surrounds his approach to the game and how that will translate to the tiki-taka style of Barcelona. Many will remember his time in charge of the Paraguayan national team, or more recently his Newell’s Old Boys side that was crowned Argentinian champions this year. Anyone who saw both of these teams would tell you they played a very distinct style of football.

Martino’s best attribute is his ability to build a strong team out of the players at his disposal. When in charge of Paraguay, he was stuck with an ageing generation without much young talent coming through, so he did what he could and formed a solid, no-nonsense side, geared towards getting results.

At Barcelona, he will have some of the greatest players in the world available to him, so his true footballing philosophy should shine through, as it did at Newell’s.

Martino’s approach to the game has its roots in bielsismo (he was the playmaker in Marcelo Bielsa’s famous 1991 Newell’s team), but with a pragmatic twist and some differences. For example, Tata’s teams mark zonally, which goes against Bielsa’s preference for man marking.

With Martino at the helm, Barcelona should not act any differently without the ball as they have done under Guardiola and Villanova. When he took charge in 2008, Pep Guardiola (himself a bielsista coach) implemented a very similar pressing system to Martino’s.

Where we may see a change however, is when Barcelona have possession. While Guardiola’s approach was to keep the ball, slow down the tempo and toy with the opposition before unleashing lightning-fast breaks into space, Martino follows the three pillars, if you will, of bielsismo: pressing, verticalidad y intensidad.

Barcelona’s “death by possession” style which we have become used to may be a thing of the past. Expect Barça to be more intense and direct under Martino.

As far as individual roles are concerned, Tata is a firm believer in attacking full-backs, but only when they are also able to track back and provide defensive cover. He also likes to have a deep, central player who can initiate attacking moves from the back. For Paraguay, he had the barrel-chested Nestor Ortigoza, while at Newell’s he had Raúl Villalba and when he left, the responsibility was passed to Santiago Vergini, a centre-back.

With Sergio Busquets un-droppable in defensive midfield, it is likely that Martino will again look to a centre-back to fill this deep playmaker role, and there are few technical defenders better than Gerard Piqué.

tata-barcelonaThe question remains of what to do with Xavi Hernández. Tata Martino’s 4-3-3 system requires the central midfielders to make darting forward runs and offer a penalty box threat (Andrés Iniesta) and Xavi – a living, breathing monument to tiki-taka – may struggle to find his place in such a role. At 33 years old, his fitness is questionable, but even when at his physical peak Xavi’s style was never about making forward bursts or scoring goals, instead it is about rhythmic, flawless passing and setting the tempo for the whole team.

It is difficult to tell while watching from afar, but Barcelona appear to have made a solid decision in appointing Tata Martino. He may never have managed in Europe before, but he arrives with a winning pedigree and more managerial experience than Frank Rijkaard, Pep Guardiola or Tito Villanova had when taking the same job.

However outstanding they may be, Barcelona looks like a team in need of a dash of fresh perspective and thinking, so bringing in Martino, someone outside of the Barça “sphere”, strikes me as a good move.

9 thoughts on “Outside of the sphere”

  1. Thanks for article on giving us some insight ti]o what Tata can do for Barcelona & what we can expect from him. I always felt there is something hidden about him even when he was managing a successful Paraguay team and were stuck to deal with Diego. Lets hope this will be the platform for him to go on for much greater things & cement his status as one the top coaches in Europe. Who knows one day, the call will come for him to take charge on the National Team.

  2. I too believe barca needed this change as last season against the big sides Milan PSG Bayern we seemed to be lost at times and running out of ideas. We dont need to change our style completely but a few more risks on the ball and a quicker style may help. Xavi makes safe passes mainly b’coz he has been given the role of an organizer and build momentum hence he cant afford making mistakes, but I feel if given permission to be more direct and take more chances he will shine and provide more assists. Barca’s pressing game and defending has been below par recently and I hope Tata can motivate players to work harder and with more intensity and bring us back to the level of 08/09. It will be interesting to see what tactics he applies against highly defensive teams and what players he buys during the summer. Really enjoyed these two articles hope they wont be the last on Tata/Barca. Good job.

    1. I will definitely be paying attention to Tata’s Barcelona team, so I don’t think this will be the last I write on the subject!
      Thanks for the comment, and interesting views on Xavi. The problem is that Martino’s centre-midfield role is a very dynamic one, and I’m not sure Xavi has the physical capacity any more. Let’s see though!

  3. Its nice reading this articles in order to know more about the incoming coach,hope he does well in order to cement his status as one of the best manager in the world,you are welcome El tata

  4. You say that Tata’s central midfielder makes “darting forward runs” and that he’s more direct than Pep. Doesn’t Cesc Fabregas fit this bill perfectly?

    1. Yes, that’s a good point. Fabregas does strike me as a player who has these qualities. But playing him would mean dropping Xavi to the bench, and I’m not sure Martino would be willing to stir things up like that.

      Perhaps a long-term measure?

      Thanks for the comment.

  5. Hey, very good analysis of Martino’s trajectory and the possible adjustments he will make to FC Barcelona. The Xavi situation is an interesting one as discussed here and am also of the opinion that Cesc should play more. He has not yer achieved the level of excellence that many of think he can reach. An interesting issue will also be the grueling schedule that Barcelona has year after year – and that is one of the things at which Martino does not have sufficient experience. Just take a look at the FC Barcelona schedule – not including UEFA Champions http://www.neymarjr.info/fc-barcelona-schedule-2013-2014/

    Keep up the good work!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s